Absolutely horrible! Esurance is a total joke, especially when you get into an accident.
Where to start… The website is the only user-friendly feature of the company. Easier to use than most other insurance websites (especially highly reputable ones), Esurance snags people in with instant quotes and instant policy. It actually takes a few business days to take effect, but it’s so easy. They are good at filing SR-22’s, but it seems to end there.
The real test of an insurance company is when you get into an accident. For this, Esurance gets an F-minus. When a drunk driver destroyed my car, I got someone on the line to report the accident, but I found that there were very few repair shops work with Esurance. Also, I gave the other party’s information to Esurance, but they seemed to be very slow in getting a hold of the other insurance company. Eventually, the insurance company got a hold of me, but it seems they got my information from the police report of the incident.
As for the settlement, they are real low-baller’s. They go way below fair market value and they also factor the insured’s deductible to give an insultingly low sum. I had to fight with Esurance quite a few times to get a better settlement (and these were the people who were supposed to be fighting for me). They only refunded the deductible when they actually settled with the DUI’s insurance company.
Subrogation - they seem ineffective in recovering the several hundred dollars I paid in out of pocket costs for the car rentals. It’s too early to tell, but I wonder if anything will materialize in the next 2 and a half years.
I just canceled my policy with them. They slapped me with a cancellation fee - how freaking stupid is this? $50 to cancel? Give me a break.
When they asked me why I was going over to another insurance agency, I tried to keep it positive. Since they insisted on pushing the questioning, I frankly told them I wanted to go with a better, more reputable insurance company.
They suck. I wouldn’t even tell my worst enemy to get insured by them.